Floating deck vs Fixed: Which is better?

Reviewed by the BuildTuff product team

Quick answer

A floating deck is freestanding and sits on deck blocks on the ground, while a fixed deck is attached to the house or supported by in-ground concrete footings. Floating decks are generally cheaper and faster to build, with no digging or concrete. Fixed decks suit raised, attached or heavy-load decks.

ground-level floating deck with outdoor dining set and wood-fired heater in a fenced backyard

Briefly, what is a floating deck?

A floating deck, also known as a ground level or freestanding deck, is a deck that is not attached to any building or structure. It is a standalone structure that is built on top of the ground and is not anchored into the ground like a traditional deck.

This means that it is not connected to the foundation of a house or other building and is not supported by in-ground concrete piers.

Instead, it is supported by preformed blocks, called deck blocks, made from concrete or engineered plastic like TuffBlock, which are placed on the ground and support the weight of the deck. Floating decks are a popular option for homeowners because they are relatively easy to build and can be placed anywhere on the property, regardless of the terrain. They can be used as a standalone structure or as an addition to an existing patio or outdoor space.

If you're planning a build and want to understand your foundation options in more detail, check out our complete floating deck blocks guide, where we explain how floating deck blocks work, how they compare to concrete footings, and what to look for when choosing a system for your project.

What are the benefits of building a floating deck?

Building a floating deck using deck blocks can be a great alternative to a traditional deck that is attached to a building or anchored into the ground using in-ground concrete piers. Here are some additional points to consider:

Cost

Deck blocks are generally less expensive than using in-ground concrete piers. This is because they do not require any digging or excavating, and the materials required are minimal. In addition, you will not need to purchase concrete mix and other supplies needed for in-ground piers.

Risk

cross-section of an in-ground concrete pier footing poured in a cardboard tube form

If you’re building in ground concrete piers, you risk hitting underground services such as water pipes, sewage pipes and electrical cables. Having these repaired can be extremely costly. By building a floating deck it removes this risk entirely.

Time

Building a floating deck with deck blocks is generally a faster process than using in-ground concrete piers. This is because the blocks are preformed and ready to use, and do not require any curing time like concrete does. In addition, the process of installing the blocks and decking boards is relatively simple and can be done in a few hours, depending on the size of your deck.

Ease of use

Deck blocks are easy to use, even for someone with limited construction experience. They are simple to install and do not require any special tools or equipment. Deck blocks allow you to alter the build slightly as you go, and gives you room for error.

Permit

building inspector in hard hat and safety vest checking plans

Floating decks may avoid the need for a building permit. In general, building a small floating deck in your backyard is considered a minor home improvement project that may not require a permit. However, it is always a good idea to check with your local building department to determine if a permit is required.

In some cases, a permit may be required if the deck exceeds a certain size or height, or if it is located in a flood zone or other regulated area. It is important to obtain the necessary permits before starting any construction project to ensure that it is built to code and to avoid any potential fines or legal issues.

To find out if a permit is required for your project, you can contact your local building department and provide them with details about the size and location of your proposed deck. They should be able to tell you if a permit is required and provide you with any necessary forms or information.

Relocating

Because the deck is not fixed to the ground, it's fairly easy to de-assemble and transport compared to a traditional deck. This might come in handy if you're living in a temporary home or moving.

Damage to vegetation

deck subframe on TuffBlock deck blocks built between existing garden plants

Digging holes and filling them with concrete can damage tree roots and vegetation. If you're building near to existing trees and plants, then avoiding the need for concreted holes can preserve your garden.

Tools & Materials Not Required

hand tools laid out on a wooden surface

A floating deck requires fewer tools and materials than an inground deck. Tools and materials you won’t need include:

Concrete mix: In-ground piers need bags of concrete mix for every footing. With deck blocks, you skip it entirely.

Concrete mixer: Concrete mixers can be expensive and are difficult to maintain. They’re the most effective way to mix concrete on site, but are fairly bulky and difficult to transport/store.

Hoe: A hoe is a long-handled tool with a flat blade that is used to mix the concrete. It is useful for breaking up any clumps of concrete mix and for stirring the mixture.

Wheelbarrow: A wheelbarrow is useful for transporting the concrete from the barrel to the location where it will be used. Although you could argue this is still a very handy tool to have for various tasks.

Trowel: A trowel is a small, flat tool with a pointed end that is used to smooth and finish the surface of the concrete.

Materials (for a floating deck)

mixing concrete in a wheelbarrow with a shovel

As discussed, a floating deck requires minimal materials.

  • Deck blocks: TuffBlocks are pre-formed deck blocks that sit under the sub-frame. They’re extremely strong and designed to fit all common joist and post sizes. They raise the deck off the ground, and as they’re made from plastic, they don’t wick water (unlike concrete).
  • Framing lumber: This makes up the joists and posts used to create the sub-frame for your deck. For a low profile deck you’ll need to purchase treated lumber.
  • Decking boards: These are the boards that will make up the surface of your deck. You can use a variety of materials, such as wood, composite, or plastic. Be sure to choose a material that is durable and suited to your needs and budget.
  • Fasteners: You will need screws to attach the decking boards to the joists. Choose screws that are appropriate for the material you are using and the size of the screws will depend on the thickness of your decking boards. You’ll also need galvanized nails when attaching your joist hangers.
  • Gravel or paver base: You may need to use gravel or sand to level the deck blocks and create a stable base for your deck. It also helps with drainage under your deck to prevent water pooling.
  • Joist hangers: These are used to connect the joists to the end joists in a way that is strong and secure. Joist hangers are an important part of a deck's structure because they help to distribute the weight of the deck evenly and provide a strong connection between the joists and the end joists.

Whichever foundation you choose, the tools for building the frame and decking are pretty much the same:

Impact driver: An impact driver is a power tool that is used to drive screws and bolts into wood, metal, and other materials. It is a more powerful and efficient tool than a traditional drill, and is particularly useful for driving long screws and bolts, or for working with dense materials.

Circular saw: You will need a circular saw to cut the decking boards to the desired length and width.

Miter saw (optional): A miter saw, also known as a drop saw or chop saw, makes fast, precise square and angled cuts. The blade is mounted on an arm that you pull down onto the board, which makes it ideal for cutting joists and decking boards to length.

Level: A level is essential to ensure that your deck is level and that the deck blocks are properly aligned.

Straight edge: A straight edge is a long, flat tool that is used to ensure that a surface is level and straight. It is a useful tool when building a deck because it helps to ensure that the decking boards are properly aligned and that the deck is level. It’s also used when trimming deck boards along a straight line.

Clamps: The most common clamps you’ll see when building a deck are bar clamps and f-clamps. Clamps are useful for a variety of tasks throughout a build. These include holding lumber in a temporary position before fastening, as well as holding deck boards in place when trimming an edge.

Hammer: You will need a hammer to drive nails into your joist hangers. A palm nailer is a good alternative to this for added speed and efficiency.

Measuring tape: A measuring tape will be needed to measure and mark the decking boards for cutting.

Chalk line: A chalk line can be used to mark straight lines on the decking boards for cutting.

Speed square: A speed square is a useful tool for marking straight lines and for ensuring that your cuts are square.

Safety glasses: It is important to wear safety glasses to protect your eyes from debris and dust when using power tools.

When is a fixed deck the better choice?

A floating deck isn't right for every project. A fixed deck, supported by in-ground concrete footings, is usually the better choice when:

  • The deck is attached to the house. A deck fixed to your home with a ledger board generally needs code-compliant footings.
  • The deck is raised high off the ground. Second-story and multi-level decks need deeper, more substantial footings.
  • It will carry heavy loads. Very large decks, or decks supporting roofs and other heavy structures, may need footings.
  • Your local code requires it. Always check with your local building department.

For ground-level, low and freestanding decks, a floating deck on deck blocks is often the simpler, faster option.

Floating deck vs fixed deck at a glance

Floating deck Fixed deck
Foundation Deck blocks sit on a compacted base Concrete piers or footings dug into the ground
Digging None A hole at every footing
Build time Faster, no concrete curing time Slower, concrete needs to cure
Cost Generally lower, no concrete or digging Generally higher
Attached to the house No, freestanding Can be attached with a ledger board
Height Best for low and ground-level decks Suits raised and multi-level decks
Permits Small, low decks may not need one Usually requires a permit

Conclusion

Building a fixed deck in a lot of cases is the appropriate option for many building projects. However, a low profile deck not attached to an existing structure provides the option to build a floating deck that has many benefits that we've covered in this article.

It's up to you to assess which route you would like to take, and weigh up the pros and cons of each building method.

Floating vs fixed deck FAQs

What is the difference between a floating deck and an attached deck?

A floating deck is freestanding and sits on deck blocks on the ground. An attached deck is fixed to the house with a ledger board and is usually supported by in-ground concrete footings.

Is a floating deck cheaper than a fixed deck?

Generally, yes. A floating deck skips the digging, concrete and curing time that in-ground footings need, which saves on materials and labor.

Does a floating deck need a permit?

It depends on where you live and on the deck's size and height. Small, low, freestanding decks often don't need one, but always check with your local building department before you start.

Can you build a floating deck on uneven ground?

Yes. On uneven or sloped ground, use deck blocks with 4x4 posts cut to different heights so the frame sits level.

TuffBlock plastic deck block, black, no-dig foundation for decks and shedsBuild a floating deckTuffBlockThe no-dig, no-concrete deck foundation. Rated 1,700 lb per block, built to ICC standards and backed by a 25-year warranty.Shop TuffBlock